Ostensibly exploring the practice of law before the internet. Heck, before good highways for that matter.
Thursday, December 4, 2025
John M. Crisp: 3 predictions for an unpredictable era
Tuesday, November 11, 2025
The Madness of King Donald. The 25th Amendment Watch List, Fifth Edition. He's not okay.
October 1, 2025
Trump's dementia is clearly accelerating, as his weird speech to assembled senior military officers demonstrated.
In response to the speeches assertion that cities like Chicago should be used as training grounds, Gov. JB Pritzker called for Trump to be removed from office under the 25th Amendment.
I've been saying that for months.
The Atlantic noted:
The president talked at length, and his comments should have confirmed to even the most sympathetic observer that he is, as the kids say, not okay. Several of Hegseth’s people said in advance of the senior-officer conclave that its goal was to energize America’s top military leaders and get them to focus on Hegseth’s vision for a new Department of War. But the generals and admirals should be forgiven if they walked out of the auditorium and wondered: What on earth is wrong with the commander in chief?
Trump seemed quieter and more confused than usual; he is not accustomed to audiences who do not clap and react to obvious applause lines. “I’ve never walked into a room so silent before,” he said at the outset. (Hegseth had the same awkward problem earlier, waiting for laughs and applause that never came.) The president announced his participation only days ago, and he certainly seemed unprepared.
I've also been stating that he's not okay.
It's now becoming undeniable even where it had been ignored. Donald Trump is not okay.
October 2, 2025
A growing momentum on Trump's insanity.
This is huge.
In this clip, an off mike Speaker of the House Mike Johnson basically admits that Trump is "unwell", and only defends it by saying that some Democrats are as well.
He doesn't defined Trump's insanity, and he claims not to have seen the speech to the Military.
There's growing momentum now for the 25th Amendment to be invoked. It's openly being called for, and here one of Trump's closest allies doesn't try to defend his sanity at all.
MADELEINE DEAN: The president is unhinged. He is unwell.
MIKE JOHNSON: A lot of folks on your side are too
DEAN: Oh my god, please. That performance in front of the generals?
MIKE JOHNSON: I didn't see it
DEAN: It's so dangerous! Our allies are looking elsewhere. Our enemies are laughing. You have a president who is unwell.
Things like this have a way of happening suddenly. Since Trump's very publized speech to the senior officers, there has been a lot of public commentary on his being "unwell" and now senior politicians are saying so openly. Some are Democrats who aren't afraid of saying it, even though they've been reluctant to up until now, such as Madelene Dean.
Dean: “Is it racist? You put a sombrero on a Black man who’s the leader of the House. You don’t see that as racist? We need you desperately to lead,”
Johnson: “I’m working on it. And personally, it’s not my style. I love you and I respect you, OK?”
Dean: “That’s why I’m talking to you".
We covered this quite a while back, but the 25th Amendment requires the vice president, together with a "majority of either the principal officers of the executive departments or of such other body as Congress may by law provide", to issue a written declaration that the president is unable to discharge his duties. So who all has to buy in on that? The majority of the cabinet, but just a simple majority.
Who all is in the cabinet?
Secretary of State Marco Rubio
Secretary of the Treasury Scott Bessent
Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth
Attorney General Pam Bondi
Secretary of the Interior Doug Burgum
Secretary of Agriculture Brooke Rollins
Secretary of Commerce Howard Lutnick
Secretary of Labor Lori Chavez-DeRemer
Secretary of Health and Human Services Robert F. Kennedy Jr.
Secretary of Housing and Urban Development Scott Turner
Secretary of Transportation Sean Duffy
Secretary of Energy Chris Wright
Secretary of Education Linda McMahon
Secretary of Veterans Affairs Doug Collins
Secretary of Homeland Security Kristi Noem
Administrator of the Environmental Protection Agency Lee Zeldin
Director of the Office of Management and Budget Russell Vought
Director of National Intelligence Tulsi Gabbard
Director of the Central Intelligence Agency John Ratcliffe
United States Trade Representative Jamieson Greer
Administrator of the Small Business Administration Kelly Loeffler
Chief of Staff Susie Wiles
Okay, let's make some reasonable assumptions.
Getting J.D. Vance on board only really requires that a majority of the cabinet go along. I suspect Vance would be pretty willing to stab Trump in the back if it elevates him to the Oval Office, and as I've said here all along, the NatCons have been planning on this development since day one.
So who might go along? Keep in mind that there are a whopping 22 cabinet officers (an absurd amount). In order to invoke the 25th Amendment, 12 would need to be willing to vote that Trump is bonkers.
Let's put them in "probable" (red), no way (blue) and unknown categories (orange) and see where that takes us, keeping in mind that unknown, is unknown to me. Others might have a pretty good idea of how everyone is likely to go.
1. Secretary of State Marco Rubio. Rubio would definitely remove Trump and is undoubtedly willing to save his own career rather than be hitched to a mentally declining unpopular President.
2. Secretary of the Treasury Scott Bessent. Bessent might seem like a surprise here, but he's been clearly uncomfortable saying the stupidest stuff and would likely like to be relieved of that burden.
1. Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth. Hegseth is hitched to Trump's wagon, and knows it. The only way he might consider otherwise is an open threat/promise that if he goes along, he keeps his job (the NatCons probably like him), but if he doesn't, when this gets worse, he'll be sent packing before his work is done.
3. Attorney General Pam Bondi. This probably seems like a surprise too, but recently Trump's been forcing Bondi into clearly unethical and stupid positions. She's pretty smart, and would likely vote to save herself.
4. Secretary of the Interior Doug Burgum. Burgum's role in the administration is a self serving marriage of convenience. He'd hitch his wagon to any Republican President.
2. Secretary of Agriculture Brooke Rollins. I don't know much about Rollins and probably should put her in orange, but she served Texas Governor Perry, which speaks for itself.
3. Secretary of Commerce Howard Lutnick. Lutnick has come across as a complete Trump toady and likely knows that if Trump falls, he's going to be sent packing.
1. Secretary of Labor Lori Chavez-DeRemer. Chavez-DeRemer has really flown under the wire, but she seems pretty sharp. She's Hispanic, and her father was a Teamster. I suspect that she'd lean towards removal as she's drawn little attention and would continue to draw little attention in a new administration.
4. Secretary of Health and Human Services Robert F. Kennedy Jr.. This one speaks for itself.
2. Secretary of Housing and Urban Development Scott Turner. Turner's an unknown. His political career has been tied to Trump, but whether he's so loyal that he'll go down with Trump is another question.
3. Secretary of Transportation Sean Duffy No idea whatsoever, but I suspect he would not go along.
5. Secretary of Energy Chris Wright Wright's weltanschauung in his department is too aligned with Trump for him to go along.
6. Secretary of Education Linda McMahon Speaks for itself.
5. Secretary of Veterans Affairs Doug Collins Collins served as an active duty and reserve chaplain. He's very conservative, but I suspect that military officers have his ear.
6. Secretary of Homeland Security Kristi Noem. Noem is from the far right, but she's savvy and she's not going to go down with the Trump ship.
7. Administrator of the Environmental Protection Agency Lee Zeldin. Zeldin is a Trump ally. He won't vote to remove Trump.
7. Director of the Office of Management and Budget Russell Vought. Vought is a far right NatCon and pretty smart, which puts him in the cynical camp. Trump's only a vehicle for the NatCons, and he'll be willing to change lines if it means it keeps the NatCons in control under a NatCon Vance. Indeed, his participation would nearly guaranty that it would.
8. Director of National Intelligence Tulsi Gabbard. Gabbard has a demonstrated independent streak and has been in both political parties. She'll act to advance and save herself.
4. Director of the Central Intelligence Agency John Ratcliffe. Quite unknown, but I suspect would lean towards removal.
5. United States Trade Representative Jamieson Greer. Unknown, but would likely lean towards removal.
6. Administrator of the Small Business Administration Kelly Loeffler. Unknown, but would likely lean towards removal.
7. Chief of Staff Susie Wiles Probably loyal to Trump.
So, if my math and ponderings are correct, which they may very well not be, things are probably nearly tied, in knowns, right now. I figure there are 8 out of the needed 12 who would remove Trump, if four more signed on.
Of the unknowns, there are seven. Of the diehard Trump loyalist, seven. I figure five of the unknowns, one more than needed, would likely go for removal, but that's a pretty thin margin. Some on the fence would likely want a greater margin.
You can bet these conversations are going on right now, however. They are openly going on now in Congress.
October 5, 2025
Don is using the budget shutdown to cozy up to Project 2025, making his removal less likely as the NatCons will get what the want from the document under the cover of the budget shutdown. Russell Vought, for example, can now be moved to the no removal column.
It was a crafty move on somebody's part.
October 15, 2025
I'd love to go to Argentina. I'd like to be like Biden. I'd like to go to the beach. My legs are not quite as thin as his. My legs are slightly heavier…My body is a little bit larger than his. I'm not sure it would be appreciated on the beach.
Donald Trump.
October 20, 2025
The destruction of the facade of the East Wing of the White House began today in anticipation of the construction of a ballroom that will never get built.
Construction of the gaudy structure will advance until the 25th Amendment or advanced old age remove Trump from office, at which point the East Wing will have to be repaired on the taxpayers dime. Worst case scenario is that Trump somehow managed to babble through a full term, which would be a disaster for the nation, after which the structure will be taken down and a new East Wing built.
October 21, 2025
So I just wanna say, thank you all. Uh, simply, behind me, so, is a knockout panel. This panel, the next time you come here, will be opened up and gone. No – uh, no problem with any of the surrounding areas. These, this room will be fixed. This will be like a cocktail – the whole floor will be cocktails or pre-briefings or whatever it may be, lots of different things. So the entire floor. So you come in, the entire floor sets up. We didn’t have to do any of that. Usually, you have to do that. You need different rooms to go along with a ballroom.
Donald Trump.
October 22, 2025
Trump now claims the justice department owes him $230M dollars.
He's clearly insane.
October 24, 2025
And with that petulant temper tantrum, we'll close out this edition.
October 30, 2025
The United States, with a demented child in the Oval Office, is going to resume the testing of nuclear weapons.
Trump is clearly, to use the legal standard, "a danger to himself or others".
Apply the 25th Amendment.
Well that's embarrassing.
November 4, 2025
Donald Trump pardoned Changpeng Zhao without knowing who he was.
This from the guy who complains about autopens.
November 5, 2025
You go to a grocery store, you have to give ID. You go to a gas station, you give ID. But for voting they want no voter ID. It's only for one reason: because they cheat.
I don't have to show an ID at the grocery store or the gas station. And I don't believe Trump ever goes to the grocery store or the gas station.
Cont:
1300% lower than last year. We love the creamed corn. I don’t know who came up with that. Bob Corn, or maybe Jack Cream. Hey look, a woman from Saudi Arabia!
Trump on creamed corn.
I don't know if they care about that in Saudi Arabia, but here it means a lot. We got the princess here from Saudi Arabia. She's got a lot of cash.
Trump on the cost of a Thanksgiving meal.
November 7, 2025
Our energy costs are way down. Our groceries are way down. Everything is way down. And the press does not report it… Thanksgiving meals 25% down. So I don't want to hear about the affordability.
Trump.
November 11, 2025
Office Hours: Trump's mental decline appears to be accelerating. So why isn’t the media reporting on it?
Related threads:
Lex Anteinternet: The Vandals.
CliffsNotes of the Zeitgeist, 104th Edition. Mike Johnson, toady, and other matters.
Lex Anteinternet: The Military Address of September 30, 2025. The Trump Speech.
Last edition:
The Madness of King Donald. The 25th Amendment Watch List, Fourth Edition.
Saturday, November 1, 2025
Gilded Age Brothel School of Interior Design
Nuclear weapons should not be entrusted to anyone pleased by Trump’s Gilded Age Brothel school of interior design.
George F. Will.
Sunday, October 26, 2025
Ezra Klein looks at the state of the Democrats. . twice.
The Ezra Klein show recently ran two really interesting vlog episodes on why the Democratic Party is in the dumpster, even as the Republican Party makes the entire country a raging dumpster fire. They're instructive, but in the case of the first one, not for the reason the guest likely hoped for.
Sunday, September 21, 2025
The Madness of King Donald. The 25th Amendment Watch List, Fourth Edition.
One of the really nutty things about the Second Trump Administration are the nuts who work for it, of which Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. is probably the nuttiest.
My vision that is every American is wearing a wearable within four years.
Robert F. Kennedy, Jr.
If a Democrat had said that, the Republicans would come unglued.
cont:
We’re going to make DC beautiful..You see what we've done at the White House. I do that in my part time because it's a natural instinct as a real estate person. I like fixing things up.
Trump on calling the Guard up in D.C. and taking over the police force.
August 13, 2025
The man who fired more than 180 shots at the headquarters of the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention was trying to send a message against COVID-19 vaccines according to authorities.
How does this relate to this topic.
COVID-19 vaccines are safe, as are the overwhelming majority of vaccines, but the populist right is anti scientific and the Trump administration has bought into far right fantasies and fueled them, as evidenced by the fact that RFK, Jr. actually has a job in the administration.
More violence by deluded wackos is a certainty.
And then, there's this.
King Donald, twice in the past few days, said he was meeting Putin in Russia, which of course he isn't. And now this:
St. Petersburg, which was founded in 1703 by Peter the Great. Peter the Great wasn't a big fan of Russians, just as Frederick the Great didn't really like Germans, and so the city wasn't given a Russian name. It was later renamed Petrograd, however. Then with the Communist came in and Lenin died, they renamed it Leningrad. In 1991 it's name was restored to St. Petersburg.
Not that Trump could be expected to know something from 34 years ago. . . .
Anyhow, this does give us a good reason to bring out the Leningrad Cowboys.
August 16, 2025
This:
Russo Ukrainian War
Trump files all the way from Washington D.C.
Putin all the way from Moscow.
Conference already over, and we still have a war.
Is there somebody who actually still takes this clown's promises seriously?
Some history (not that Trump would appreciate it).
New Yorker Theodore Roosevelt negotiated the end of the Russo Japanese War, from the US, from August 9, 1905, through August 30, 1905.
But then, Roosevelt was a genuine article.
So, Trump flies all day to Alaska to a U.S. Air Force Base which has to prepare for his, and Putin's arrival.
Putin flies all day to Anchorage as well.
They meet for four hours, and Trump then talks to the press about "Vladimir" saying this or that.
A person would have to be intensely stupid to believe that a four hour meeting was going to accomplish anything. Of course, nothing was going to happen without a Ukrainian delegate being there.
Trump is now well. 25th Amendment now.
August 17, 2025
A Trump tweet would appear to place Trump pathetically fully in the Putin camp today:
Basically this means Ukraine can end the war by surrendering, to the extent its capable of being deciphered.
If Trump was a drinking man, which he's not, this would look like a drunk tweet.
August 18, 2025
One thing we've learned from the Trump meeting with Putin is how massively weak as a character he really is, and how extremely insecure he is.
It was obvious going into it that welcoming Putin to U.S. soil was a mistake, but Trump disregarded any counsel other than his own and looked like a gleeful little boy when Putin showed up. Putin shoved him around like a weakling and the meeting ended a couple of hours later, and ever since then Trump's been trying to figure out what to do, having landed, finally, on just agreeing to demand what Putin insisted he did.
When negotiations with the North Vietnamese broke down in Paris, which took months, not hours, Nixon ordered the resumption of B-52 strikes. Nixon, who wasn't generally admirable, but who looks better all the time in comparison to Trump, wasn't a weakling.
Donny, it turns out, really is. He's pathetic, in the true sense of the world. Demanding attention, demanding love, and have petulant fits when he doesn't get it. He is truly childish.
A situation a declining mental state doesn't help at all.
August 19, 2025
Now King Donny wants to do away with voting machines and mail in ballots.
This may be a "don't ask about the Epstein Files" distaction, as a segment of his MAGA base already held those views. Harriet Hageman was asked about it last night in Casper and demurred.
Trump, yesterday, called the Democratic Republic of Congo, the "Republic of the Condo.
August 21, 2025
He’s in there fighting, they’re trying to put him in jail on top of everything else, how about that? He’s a war hero because we worked together. He’s a war hero. I guess I am too.
Donald Trump about Netanyahu and himself.
Trump, a war hero?
Things must not be going well for Trump in general right now, as J.D. Vance has reemerged. Vance usually appears when Trump's backers figure that he can't be trusted not to say really stupid things in the face of tough questions. Otherwise Vance wisely hides in the background, probably hoping the stench doesn't attach to him too strongly.
August 25, 2025
Donald Trump is now threatening Chris Christie, formerly an ally and now a critic (like John Bolton) with prosecution.
Those who warned that Trump would be a vindictive autocrat have been proven correct.
By the way, Trump criticizing somebody's hair is rather extreme. His own hair is extremely weird, and the other day he wore a trucker's cap in the Oval Office.
August 26, 2025
China intelligently went in and they sort of took a monopoly of the world's magnets. Nobody needed magnets until they convinced everybody 20 years ago, 'let's all do magnets.' There were many other ways that the world could have gone ... we're heavily into the world of magnets now.
Donald Trump.
cont:
We send hundreds of millions of gallons of water a day to the Pacific Ocean. They turn a valve and the valve heads out. And we turned the valve back. I actually had to do it using force. We turned the valve back and now they have water.
Donald Trump.
August 27, 2025
His supporters will excuse them, and the rest of the country is numb, but Trump's latest press session demonstrated ramblings that were flat out bat shit crazy.
This is frightening for a variety of reasons. He's clearly nuts. But beyond that, he's drawing bizarre sycophantic praise from his cabinet members. They're sharing in his sickness. And this isn't limited to just his cabinet. One comment I saw on John Barrasso, the Senate Whip and Wyoming's senior senator fairly accurately characterized him at this point as an "ass kissing sycophant."
The really scary part is that Trump may have so surrounded himself with a loyal Reichsregierung that there may actually no will to invoke the 25th Amendment, as frankly the time has come. And if that's the case, were rocketing into unrecoverable Trump dictatorship with nobody to apply the brakes.
August 28, 2025
I’m looking at kids as I walk through the airports today...and I see these kids that are just overburdened with mitochondrial challenges, inflammation—you can tell from their faces, movements, and lack of social connection
RFK, Jr.
September 2, 2025
Lots of people are doing a 25th Amendment watch today. Trump has announced a "major" address today at 2:00 p.m. ET, and roads around Walter Reed are apparently restricted today.
Chances are that it will amount to absolutely nothing.
cont:
It's now rumored that the announcement will be that the headquarters for the Space Farce will be moved.
cont:
And, indeed, that was the news. The Space Farce, formed during Trump's first administration, is being moved to Alabama.
It should be moved to the dustbin of history and its mission restored to the Air Force.
cont:
Additionally, Trump attributed his decision to move his pet military branch to Alabama on Colorado having bad voting laws.
It doesn't have bad voting laws, this is just more of Trump's demented vengeful nature coming out.
September 5, 2025
SENATORS GRILL RFK JR. IN RAUCOUS HEARING
Headline in the Trib.
Kennedy is a nut.
And this from the man who never served a day in the military:
Trump to change DOD to ‘Department of War’
September 11, 2025
Reporter: My condolences on the loss of your friend Charlie Kirk. How are you holding up?Trump: Very good. And BTW, right there you see all the trucks. They just started construction of the new ballroom for the WH…it's gonna be a beauty
THE GOLD CARDExecutive OrdersSeptember 19, 2025By the authority vested in me as President by the Constitution and the laws of the United States of America, it is hereby ordered:Section 1. Purpose. My Administration has worked relentlessly to undo the disastrous immigration policies of the prior administration. Those policies produced a deluge of immigrants, without serious consideration of how those immigrants would affect America’s interests.Most significantly, the prior administration permitted millions of aliens to enter the United States illegally, to the detriment of public safety, national security, and the rule of law. International cartels, transnational criminal organizations, terrorists, and foreign malign actors took advantage of those open borders policies. The prior administration also permitted abuse of the refugee process, swamping towns and cities with aliens and, in some cases, forcing them to declare emergencies to combat the crisis.It is a priority of my Administration to realign Federal immigration policy with the Nation’s interests by ending illegal immigration and prioritizing the admission of aliens who will affirmatively benefit the Nation, including successful entrepreneurs, investors, and businessmen and women.To advance that policy, I hereby announce the Gold Card, a visa program overseen by the Secretary of Commerce that will facilitate the entry of aliens who have demonstrated their ability and desire to advance the interests of the United States by voluntarily providing a significant financial gift to the Nation.Sec. 2. The Gold Card. (a) The Secretary of Commerce, in coordination with the Secretary of State and the Secretary of Homeland Security, shall establish a “Gold Card” program authorizing an alien who makes an unrestricted gift to the Department of Commerce under 15 U.S.C. 1522 (or for whom a corporation or similar entity makes such a gift) to establish eligibility for an immigrant visa using an expedited process, to the extent consistent with law and public safety and national security concerns. The requisite gift amount shall be $1 million for an individual donating on his or her own behalf and $2 million for a corporation or similar entity donating on behalf of an individual.(b) In adjudicating visa applications, the Secretary of State and the Secretary of Homeland Security shall, consistent with applicable law, treat the gift specified in subsection (a) of this section as evidence of eligibility under 8 U.S.C. 1153(b)(1)(A), of exceptional business ability and national benefit under 8 U.S.C. 1153(b)(2)(A), and of eligibility for a national-interest waiver under 8 U.S.C. 1153(b)(2)(B).(c) The Secretary of Commerce shall deposit the gifts contributed under subsection (a) of this section in a separate fund in the Department of the Treasury and use them to promote commerce and American industry, consistent with the statutory authorities of the Department of Commerce, see, e.g., 15 U.S.C. 1512.Sec. 3. Implementation. The Secretary of Commerce, the Secretary of State, and the Secretary of Homeland Security shall, within 90 days of the date of this order, take all necessary and appropriate steps to implement the Gold Card program. Among other things, they shall, to the extent consistent with applicable law and their respective statutory authorities, including the limits on the numbers of visas specified in 8 U.S.C. 1151 et seq.:(a) Establish a process for application and expedited adjudication of Gold Card petitions, visa issuance, and adjustment of status.(b) Specify the date on which applicants (or sponsors if applicable) may begin to submit gifts for consideration under the Gold Card program.(c) Establish a process for a Gold Card holder sponsored by a corporation or similar entity to abandon his or her status and for the Secretary of State and the Secretary of Homeland Security to consider the original gift as evidence of eligibility under 8 U.S.C. 1153(b)(1)(A), of exceptional business ability and national benefit under 8 U.S.C. 1153 (b)(2)(A), and of eligibility for a national-interest waiver under 8 U.S.C. 1153(b)(2)(B), for a different individual specified by the corporation or similar entity. The transferee shall otherwise be subject to the same procedures as an original visa applicant, including appropriate screening for public safety and national security.(d) Establish administrative fees to cover the cost of expedited processing under subsection (a) of this section.(e) Establish maintenance and transfer fees for corporations or similar entities sponsoring individuals under the Gold Card program.(f) Consider expanding the Gold Card program to visa applicants under 8 U.S.C. 1153(b)(5).Sec. 4. Severability. If any provision of this order, or the application of any provision to any person, is held to be invalid, the remaining provisions and applications shall not be affected thereby.Sec. 5. General Provisions. (a) Nothing in this order shall be construed to impair or otherwise affect:(i) the authority granted by law to an executive department or agency, or the head thereof; or(ii) the functions of the Director of the Office of Management and Budget relating to budgetary, administrative, or legislative proposals.(b) This order shall be implemented consistent with applicable law and subject to the availability of appropriations.(c) This order is not intended to, and does not, create any right or benefit, substantive or procedural, enforceable at law or in equity by any party against the United States, its departments, agencies, or entities, its officers, employees, or agents, or any other person.(d) The costs for publication of this order shall be borne by the Department of Commerce.DONALD J. TRUMPTHE WHITE HOUSE,September 19, 2025.
Last edition:
The Madness of King Donald. The 25th Amendment Watch List, Third Edition and Cliffnotes of the Zeitgeist, 98th edition. The Perverts and Fellow Travelers Issue.
Thursday, August 28, 2025
A deeply sick society.
We make men without chests and expect of them virtue and enterprise. We laugh at honor and are shocked find traitors in our midsts. We castrate and bid the geldings be fruitful.
Let's start with a couple of basics.
You were born a man, or a woman. We all were, and you can't change that. If you are a man, no amount of surgery or drugs is going to make you bear life and bear all the consequences of the same, from hormonal storms on a monthly basis, to monthly blood loss, to a massive change of life, mid life.
Thinking that you can, and even wanting to makes you deeply mentally ill.
And a society that tolerates that attempt, is deeply sick.
An account I follow on Twitter notes the following:
22 years old Was 17 years old when Covid hitI wonder when he started going down the trans path
It's worth asking that question, and we'll touch on it in a moment.
Part I.
Robert Westman, mentally ill young man, raged against the reality of life that had tolerated his perverted molestation of himself and lashed out against the existential nature that doomed his molestation to complete failure, and a deeply sick society now will wonder why. Moreover, even his final act shows how deeply he failed in his effort. Women nearly never resort to mass violence in frustration.
That's a male thing.
And so we start, again by finding myself linking back to some old threads on this blog, unfortunately. This was the first time I tackled this topic.
Lex Anteinternet: Peculiarized violence and American society. Looki...: Because of the horrific senseless tragedy in Newton Connecticut, every pundit and commentator in the US is writing on the topic of what cau...
And I did again here:
Lex Anteinternet: You Heard It Here First: Peculiarized violence an...: (Note. This is a post I thought I'd posted back in November. Apparently not, I found it in my drafts, incomplete. So I'm posting...
The first time was intended to be the magnum opus on this, and indeed it likely still is. It's still worth reading:
Peculiarized violence and American society. Looking at root causes, and not instrumentalities.
Peculiarized violence and American society. Looking at root causes, and not instrumentalities.
And on that, I'm going right to this:
And also this:
Maybe the standard was destroyed
No place to go, and the lessons of the basement and entertainment.
All of that is still valid, and in particular, I think, we need to consider again:
Over the coming days and weeks pundits will ponder this event, and mostly spout out blather. The explanation here may have deeply disturbing aspects to it, but the underlying root of it is not that complicated. Robert Westman fell into the trap that ensnares some of the young in our society and hoped to completely change his nature by changing the outward morphology of his nature. He was mentally ill.
A just society treats compassionately the mentally ill.
We do not live in a just society.
By and large, we just turn the mentally ill out into the street to allow their afflictions to grow worse until those afflictions kill them. Go to any big city and you'll see the deranged and deeply addicted out in the street. This is not a kindness.
Gender Dysphoria is a different type of mental illness, but that's what it is.2
And its deeply delusional.
To put it bluntly to the point of being crude, no man, no matter what they attempt to do, is going to bear children and have the risk of bearing children, bleed monthly, and be subject to the hormonal storms that real women are subject to. And, frankly, men generally become subject to some, if varying, degrees of drives that are constant and relenting, and never abate.3
No woman, no matter what she attempts to do, is going to hit a certain age in their teens have their minds turn to women almost constantly, as men do, in a way that women do not understand, and frankly do not experience the opposite of themselves.
Indeed, no man really wants to be a woman, or vice versa. What those engaging in an attempt to pass through a gender barrier seek is something else, and what that more often than not in the case of men likely is to drop out of the heavy male burdens in an age in which it increasingly difficult to meet them. In spite of everything in the modern world, women remain conceived of as more protected, and therefore not as subject to failure for not meeting societal expectations.
Being a man has never been easy.
In the days of my youth, I was told what it means to be a man
And now I've reached that age
I've tried to do all those things the best I can
No matter how I try, I find my way into the same old jam
Good Times, Bad Times, by Led Zeppelin.
I don't think lectures on what it means to be a man occur anymore. I know that I've never delivered one, but I didn't need one to be delivered either. The examples were clearly around me, including all the duties that entailed. We knew, growing up, that good men didn't abandon their families, and provided for their families, and were expected to protect women to the point of their own deaths. Women weren't expected to protect men, at all.
Some men have always sought to escape their obligations, of course, and we all know or new those who did. Most aged into disrepute over time. Others got their acts together.
You can’t be a man at night if you are a boy all day long.
Rev. Wellington Boone.
And some have always descended into madness. But society didn't tolerate it, and it shouldn't have to.
So what do we know about Westman?
Not that much, but what we do know is revealing:
- He killed himself after his cowardly murders.
- He'd developed an inclination towards violence.4
- He once attended the Catholic school whose students he attacked, leaving in 2017 at the end of Middle School.
- He started identifying as a female in 2019, age 17, and his mother signed the petition to change his name.5
- After middle school attended a charter school and then the all-boys school, Saint Thomas Academy, which is a Catholic military school. 6
- An uncle said he barely knew him.7
- His parents were divorced when he was 13.
- He worked at a cannabis dispensary, but was a poor employee.8
What can we tell from this?
Maybe nothing at all, but the keys are that in spite of they're being Catholic, his parents divorced, and his mother thereafter tolerated to some degree his drift into delusion, while at the same time there's evidence they were trying to correct it. After school, he drifted into drugs, which is what marijuana is.
Blame the parents? Well, that would be too simple. But societal tolerance of divorce and transgender delusion is fostering all sorts of societal ills.
It's notable that he struck out at a childhood school. That may be all the more his violence relates, but probably not. His mother had worked there. He was likely striking out at her too. And he was striking out an institution that doesn't accept that you can change your existential nature, because you cannot. He likely was fully aware of that, which is why he acted out with rage at it, and then killed himself.
There may, frankly, be an added element to this, although only recently have people in the secular world, such as Ezra Klein, began to discuss it. Westman may have been possessed.
Members of the American Civil Religion don't like to discuss this at all, and frankly many conventional Christians do not either. Atheist and near atheist won't acknowledge it all, of course. But Westman's flirting with perverting nature may have frankly lead him into a really dark place, and not just in the conventional sense.
Part 2. What should we do?
Well, what will be done is nothing. Something should, however, be done.
The topic of gun control will come up, which brings us back to this:
You Heard It Here First: Peculiarized violence and American society. It Wasn't The Guns That Changed, We Changed (a post that does and doesn't go where you think it is)
We're going to hear, from more educated quarters defending the Second Amendment, that firearms have not really changed all that much over the years, society has. This is completely true.
But we're at the point now that we need to acknowledge that society has changed. And that means a real effort to keep firearms out of the hands of the mentally ill needs to be undertaken.
When the Constitution was written, Americans were overwhelmingly rural. Agrarianism was the norm everywhere. People generally lived in a family dwelling that included everyone from infants to the elderly. Normally the entire community in which a person lived was of one religion, and everyone participated in religious life to some degree. Even communities that had more than one religion represented, still had everyone being members of a faith. Divorce was not at all common, and in certain communities not tolerated whatsoever.9
Westman was mentally ill. Transgenderism is a mental illness. He was a drug user. Cannabis is a drug.
In 1789 the mentally ill, if incapable of functioning, would have been taken care of at home by their families. Transgenderism would not have been conceived of and not tolerated. Alcohol was in heavy use. Marijuana was not. The plethora of narcotics now in circulation were not conceived of.
Yes, this will sound extreme. Am I saying that because a tiny number of transgendered might resort to violence they shouldn't own guns? Yes, maybe in a society that simply chooses to tolerate mental illness, that's what I'm saying, although it also strikes me that the people who have gone down this deluded path might be amongst those most needing firearms for self protection. So, not really. I am saying that attention needs to be focused on their mental state.
Am I saying that marijuana users shouldn't own guns? Yes, that is also what I'm saying, along with other chronic users of drugs, legal and illegal.
And as we choose to simply ignore mental illness, perhaps the time has come to see if a would be gun owners is mentally stable and societally responsible before allowing them to own guns. People in chronic debt, with violent behavior, with unacknowledged children in need shouldn't be owning firearms.
Of note, at the time the Second Amendment was written, none of these things was easily tolerated.
Part 3. Getting more extreme.
Knowing that none of this will occur, I'll go there anyhow.
Societal tolerance of some species of mental illness should just end. There shouldn't be homeless drug addicts on the street and gender reassignment surgery and drugs should be flat out illegal.
For that matter, in the nature of extreme, plastic surgery for cosmetic reasons should be banned. Your nose and boobs are fine the way they are, leave them alone.
No fault divorce should end, and for that matter people who have children should be deemed married by the state, with all the duties that implies. Multiple children by multiple partners should be regarded as engaging in polygamy, which should still be regarded as illegal.
Love between man and woman cannot be built without sacrifices and self-denial. It is the duty of every man to uphold the dignity of every woman.
St. John Paul II.
Yes, that's rough.
Life is tough for all of us. Ignoring that fact makes it harder on all of us.
Part 4. Doesn't this all play into Dementia Don and his Sycophantic Twatwaffles?
Unfortunately, it does. I fear that this may prove to be the Trump Administration's Reichstag moment.
Indeed, this event is like a gift to people like Stephen Miller who will now assert that this came about due to the liberal policies of Minneapolis, and moreover, as proof that outright attacks on transgendered are needed, the same way the Nazis asserted that dictatorship was necessary in Germany after the Reichstag fire.
Isn't that what' I'm stating?
I am not.
I think we need to address mental illness as a mental illness, and do what we can to treat it. And rather obviously, what I've stated above doesn't square with Second Amendment hardcore advocates.
And as part of that, we need to get back to acknowledging that the mentally ill are mentally ill, rather than "tolerating" it.
And we need to quite tolerating "personal freedom" over societal protection, right down to the relationship level. A married couple produced this kid. Once they did that, they were in it, and the marriage, for life. That included the duty not to make dumb ass decisions for their child, like changing Robert's name to Robin.
Part 5. What will happen?
Absolutely nothing.
People on the right will argue its not the guns, it's the sick society. People on the left will argue that the society isn't sick, except for the guns, and the guns are all of the problem.
Nothing, therefore, will occur.
Well, maybe.
If anything occurs, it'll be that Dementia Don will use it as an excuse to send the National Guard into Minneapolis.
Footnotes
1. His name was Robert, not "Robin". The free use of female names for men afflicted by this condition and the press use of "she" for what is properly he, is part of the problem.
2 By gender confusion, I"m referring to Gender Dysphoria, or whatever people are calling it, not homosexuality. Homosexuals don't fit into this discussion at all. For one thing, homosexuals are not confused about what gender they are.
3. This does not advocate for license, although some men argue that it does. Inclinations are not a pass for immorality.
Anyhow, I'd note that even honest men in cebate professions acknowledge this. Fr. Joseph Krupp, the podcaster, frequently notes having a crush, for example, on Rachel Weisz.
4. Again, some women grow violent, but its a minority and, when it occurs, tends to be accompanied by something else. There are exceptions.
5. I don't know all of the details of his personal life, of course, but that was inexcusable on his mother's part. I'll note, however, that by this time his parents were divorced and no woman is capable of raising children completely on her own. Again, I don't know what was going on, but this screams either extreme "progressive" views, or a mostly absent father, or extreme fatigue.
6. I didn't even know that there were Catholic military schools.
Military schools have always been institutions for troubled boys, and this suggests that there was an attempt to put him in a masculine atmosphere and hopefully straighten him out. The school had both a religious base and a military nature. Both of his parents must have participated in this.
7. The modern world fully at work. People move for work, careers, etc., with the result that nuclear families basically explode, nuclear bomb style. People more and more are raised in families that are the immediate parental unit, or just one parent, that start to disintegrate the moment children turn 18. This is not natural, and is part of the problem.
8. I don't know of course, but I'd guess that in order to be a poor employee at a cannabis dispensary, you have to be a really poor employee. There are bars with bartenders who don't drink, but I bet there aren't any dispensaries with employees that aren't using.
The impacts of marijuana use are very poorly understood, but as it becomes more and more legal, that there are negative psychological impacts for long term and chronic use is pretty clear.
9. Contrary to widespread belief, not only Catholicism prohibits divorce. The Anglican Communion does not either, and at that time particularly did not tolerate it. Divorce occurred, but it was not common.
Also, and we've touched on it before, the United States at the time of its founding was a Christian nation. It was a Protestant Christian nation, but a Christian nation. Protestants of the 19th Century would not recognize many Protestant denominations today at all, even if they are theoretically the same. A 1790s Episcopalian, for example, would be horrified by many Episcopalian congregations today. In contrast, a Catholic or Orthodox person would find the churches pretty recognizable, save for the languages used for services.












