On this day in 1921 one of the most infamous, most misreported, and one of the most still most mysterious deaths in Hollywood history occurred. And one that features all the things that still cause Hollywood to fascinate and repel.
The death of young actress Virginia Rappe.
Even though the critical events in the death of Rappe, then age 26, occurred at a party, where lot of people were around, what really occurred leading to her untimely death remains a mystery. From what seems to be clear, we can tell the following.
Rappe was a guest at a party hosted by Fred Fischbach, a friend of celebrated silent movie comedian Roscoe "Fatty" Arbuckle. The party was partially in celebration of a hit Arbuckle movie, Crazy To Marry. The five reel movie was a recent release and doing well, although it is now obscure and may be in the category of lost film (I'm not sure of that). At the time, Arbuckle was making $1,000,000 a year from films, a gigantic sum not only now, for most people, but particularly then, given the respective value of a dollar compared to now. Arbuckle, we'd note, was married, with his spouse at the time being Minta Durfee, although the couple had recently separated. In spite of that, it should be further noted, Durfee would call Arbuckle in later years the most generous man she'd ever met, and that in spite of their 1925 divorce, if given the choice, she'd do it all again.
Minta Durfee.
Fischback rented three hotel rooms, and, in the spirit of the times, supplied them with large quantifies of bootleg booze. Rappe was an invited guest, and arrived with Bambina Maude. At the party Rappe drank a lot of alcohol. At some point in the party it seems that he and Rappe went into room 1219 of the hotel alone, and shortly thereafter some sort of commotion occurred, Arbuckle emerged and Rappe was desperately sick. She was taken to the hospital and died four days later from a ruptured bladder and peritonitis.
One of the hotel rooms after the party.
Arbuckle was arrested and accused of rape and manslaughter, with an essential element of the accusation being that forced sex had caused Rappe's death.
Seems, at first blush, clear enough, but it gets very confused from there.
Arbuckle maintained his innocence throughout. He was tried three times, resulting in two mistrials, and then an acquittal. Bambina Maude was a witness in the story, filling in lurid details, but she was later revealed to be a procurer who used that role to blackmail recipients of the favors she'd arranged to supply, although there was no evidence that she was acting as a procurer at the time of the attendance at the party. Indeed, while there are multiple stories as to what occured, one of the versions that exists is that the room that Rappe went into was the only one with a bathroom and she went into it to throw up, going through the bedroom where Maude was having sex with a movie director. In that version, which isn't the only one, Arbuckle went in the room to carry the collapsed Rappe out. [1].
The final jury apologized to Arbuckle for what he'd been through. And, indeed, it seems fairly clear that whatever occurred between Arbuckle and Rappe, it wasn't that which resulted in her death, but rather a chronic medical condition that was exacerbated by alcohol. It's likely her drinking at the party, which killed her.
Rappe, who was at one time regarded as the "best dressed girl in films".
Even that, however, doesn't flesh the entire tragic story out. Rappe was only 26, but by that age was already a photographic veteran, having worked as an orphan raised by her grandmother as a model since age 14. She had some trouble holding alcohol and was inclined to strip when drunk. She'd been the live in with Henry Lehamn only fairly recently, to whom she'd been engaged. According to at least some sources, which may be doubted given that they are a century old, she was freer with her affections than the norms of the time would have endorsed.
What occurred between Arbuckle and Rappe is not known and never well be and now too much time has passed to sort it out. About as much as we can tell is that it seems that Arbuckle might have made some sort of advance on Rappe and that at first Rappe might have welcomed it. That she was desperately ill is clear. Her illness killed her.
This, in turn, provides an interesting look at public morals and standards, then and now. At least some of the conduct Rappe and Arbuckle were engaging in was immoral by Christian standards, and Christian standards were clearly the public standards of the day. Be that as it may, it's clear that in his trials, the fact that Arbuckle was doing something with a drunk woman doesn't seem to have been held against him, or at least it ultimately wasn't. Of course, maybe the jurors didnt' feel he was doing anything with her, or even aiding her, or at least some must have thought that in all three trials. If Arbuckle was advancing on her, it most definitely would be regarded as improper today. Having said that, it wasn't all that long ago that "get her drunk" was sort of a joke which implied that inebriation to the point of being unable to consent was consent.
Arbuckle's career would never recover from the evening. Perhaps, in some ways, it shouldn't have. He wasn't a killer, but what occurred was unconscionable for other reasons. . reasons we seemingly have managed to forget, however, over the years. Even after his acquittal he was more or less blackballed in the industry for a time, and then when that was lifted his star power was gone. He changed his name and made a much smaller living behind the scenes before starting to stage a minor comeback in the 1930s. He died in 1933 in a hotel room from a heart attack. He was 46.
Arbuckle movie poster from 1932.
It's interesting to see how this event compares to contemporary ones. We have a person in attendance at the party who associated with the rich and famous whose role seems to have been supplying female favors (Maude), much like Jeffrey Epstein and his hangers on have been accused of. We have a Hollywood set who lived personal lives that departed greatly from public standards, something that's still the case, although less so now as standards have declined so much, and we might have some sort of sexual contact between a male Hollywood figure and a very drunk actress (or not), something that in our contemporary culture would be a career ending event irrespective of the accusations of rape. Indeed, accusations of rape in Hollywood, not all of which are substantiated, have become very common in recent years.
In the end it was a terrible tragedy. People thought they were going to a party Rappe probably knew she was drinking too much. Arbuckle surely knew he shouldn't make advances on her. Death came like a "thief in the night", which nobody anticipated.
On the same day, elsewhere, the League of Nations convened for the second time and admitted Albania, Austria, Bulgaria, Finland and Luxembourg.
Footnotes:
1 Yet another version, upon which a book was written asserts that Rappe had received botched abortion that had nicked her bladder, and it ruptured when she tickled Arbuckle and he accidentally kneed her.
Others criticize that assertion, which would by definition be based on a large element of speculation. It seems based on Rappe having reported received something like five prior abortions in an era when they were all fully illegal.