Showing posts with label Korean War. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Korean War. Show all posts

Thursday, February 1, 2024

Friday, February 1, 1924. Wilson in grave condition.


Woodrow Wilson was gravely ill.

Hiester Richard Hornberger Jr., better known by his pen name, Richard Hooker, was born in New Jerseay.  A physician who practiced in Maine, he's remembered for his novel M*A*S*H which was based on his experiences as an Army doctor during the Korean War.

Wednesday, January 31, 2024

Wars and Rumors of War, 2024. Part I. New Year, last year's wars.

You will hear of wars and rumors of wars, but see to it that you are not alarmed. Such things must happen, but the end is still to come. Nation will rise against nation, and kingdom against kingdom.

Matthew, Chapter 24.


Only the dead have seen the end of the war.

George Santayana

January 1, 2024

Russo Ukrainian War

This major war is now in its third calendar year.

Hamas Israeli War

The Prime Minister of Israel has stated that this campaign will carry on for many months.

An Israeli airstrike killed 35 in Gaza.

The U.S. Navy sunk three Houthi boats attempting to attack a merchant vessel.

Venezuela v Guyana border dispute.

Venezuela is conducting a joint arms exercise in response to the Royal Navy dispatching a ship to Guyana.

January 2, 2024

Russo Ukrainian War

A change in Norwegian law allows Norwegian arms manufacturers to sell arms directly to Ukraine.

How much of a defense industry Norway has, of course, is another matter.

January 3, 2024

Hamas Israeli War

An Israeli airstrike sent Saleh Arouri to the next world, where he will have to make an account for his actions.  An Islamic radical his entire life, he was the founder of Hamas' military wing.  

He went to his end in Beirut.

From ISW:

Israeli forces are transitioning to the third phase of their operations in the northern Gaza Strip, which will very likely enable Hamas to reconstitute itself militarily. The Israel Defense Forces (IDF) confirmed that it withdrew five brigades from the northern Gaza Strip on December 31. This reduction in forces is part of what the IDF has described as its third phase in the strip, which also involves ending major combat operations, releasing reservists, transitioning to “targeted raids,” and establishing a security buffer zone within the Gaza Strip.

January 4, 2024

US/Mexico Border Crisis

The Justice Department has sued Texas on over a new law that would allow Texas police to arrest illegal immigrants on the basis of their illegality. 

My prediction is that this suit will likely fail.

Hamas Israeli War

Hezbollah leader Seyyed Hassan Nasrallah warned Israel that launching a full-scale war on Lebanon Islamist targets would be "very costly," and that the assassination of a senior Hamas leader in Beirut would not go unpunished.

Sort of in the D'uh category.

Cont:

Islamic State v. Iran

The Islamic State claimed responsibility for a bombing attack that killed 84 people in Kerman, Iran.  The attack occured during a memorial procession for Maj. Gen. Qassim Suleimani.  The Sunni group regards Shiites, which most Iranians are, with Iran being a Shiite theocracy, as apostates.

January 5, 2024

Russo Ukrainian War

Putin signed a decree signed speeding up citizenship for foreigners enlisting in the Russian army.

Somalian Civil War

From ISW: 

Ethiopia signed a memorandum of understanding with the de facto independent Somaliland Republic, a breakaway region of Somalia, to lease a naval port that will give it Red Sea access in exchange for formally recognizing Somaliland.

January 7, 2024

The Korean Conflict

North Korea issued one of its threatening proclamations through Communist princess Kim Yo Jong.

These are moronic, as without China, and North Korea cannot really depend on China, South Korea would be eliminated as an entity in the event of war.

South Korea may soon not be able to fill its conscript levies due to a declining population.

Russo Ukrainian War

Japan's foreign minister visited Ukraine.

Russia seems to have resumed its strategy of attempting localized offensives that degrade its own forces.

The Ukrainians have been conducting a drone offensive against targets in Crimea.

January 9, 2024

Russo Ukrainian War

News reports hold that Russia has deployed 35,000 men of the Russian National Guard, some equipped with World War Two vintage rifles, to occupied regions of Ukraine as security forces.

January 10, 2024

Hamas Israeli War

Anthony Blinken has indicated the US rejects the concept of resettling the Gazan Levantines from that area even though, of course, its an untenable ghetto. 

Iran v. The West

Iranian backed Houthis launched 50 drones at shipping today, all of which were shot down by the U.S. Navy and Royal Navy.

Iran is using the current Hamas Israeli War as a pretext to try to advance its interest in the region.

January 11, 2024

Hamas Israeli War

The US and UK hit targets with missiles inside of Yemen, from which Houthi drone strikes have been coming. A Houthi spokesman actually complained about it.

January 12, 2024

Russo Ukrainian War

From ISW:

Mexican Border Crisis.

The State of Texas, using the Texas National Guard, has seized Shelby Park in Eagle Pass in order to prevent Federal authorities from processing migrants.

January 13, 2024

Hamas Israeli War.

The US struck Houthi targets again yesterday.

Turkey v. Kurds

Turkish air raids struck Kurdish militant targets in Metina, Hakurk, Gara and Qandil in northern Iraq. This was in retaliation for a Kurdish attack on a Turkish base in Iraq.

January 16, 2024

Iran v Everyone

Iran’s Revolutionary Guards launched missile attacks in Syria and in Iraq’s Kurdistan region yesterday.

Korean Conflict

The North Korean Communist Clown state announced it is no longer pursuing reconciliation with South Korea, which actually dovetails nicely with general younger South Korean desires.

There's speculation on why this was announced, but in reality, any reunion between the countries at this point makes the ongoing Communist monarchy in North Korean irrelevant in every fashion so quickly, it isn't funny.

January 17, 2024

Hamas Israeli War/Iran v Everyone

The US is placing the Houthi's back on the terrorist list.

Iran v. Everyone

Iran conducted missile strikes on a Sunni militia site in Pakistan.

January 18, 2024

Hamas Israeli War/Iran v Everyone

The US conducted a fourth round of strikes on the Houthis.

Pakistan v. Baloch militants.

Pakistan conducted strikes inside Iran against Baloch militants.

January 20, 2024

Russo Ukrainian War

The Estonian state will not extend the residence permit of the head of the Estonian Orthodox Church (Russian Orthodox Church in Estonia) of the Moscow Patriarchate, Metropolitan Yevgeniy, whose civil name is Valeri Reshetnikov, because his activities are a security threat to Estonia

Estonian government.

Cont:

The Middle East

Somebody (probably Israel) hit Iranian Revolutionary Guard figures inside of Syria.  In turn, US sites in Iraq were hit.by Iranian backed militia's.

Iran is the common thread here. 

January 21, 2024

Hamas Israeli War

Benjamin Netanyahu rejected a two state solution for Gaza.

This is widely seen as a terrible thing to have done, but frankly, Gaza isn't viable as an isolated political unit and always has depended on economic support from the outside to get by. Geographically, it should be part of Israel or Egypt, and that's a simple economic and topographic fact.  It shouldn't be part of another state.

For that matter, a Palestinian state makes little to no sense.  It would be minute.

Those are the rough, real facts to deal with.  Levantines that live within the borders of what had been pre-1948 Palestine either have to live within Israel, realistically, or be relocated in some instances to an Arab state that could host them, none of which are willing to do it.

Russo Ukrainian War

President Zylenskyy expressed concerns about remarks made by Donald Trump regarding securing peace.

Concern is warranted given Trump's admiration for dictators and his increasingly erratic if not demented behavior.

January 22, 2024

China v. Taiwan

Recent statements by GOP candidate Donald Trump have risen concerns that his commitment to Taiwan, which has been a GOP hallmark, is low.  

FWIW, Trump raised Taiwanese semiconductor production as something the US should have done something about, seemingly failing to grasp that if it falls to China, we're in a world of semiconductor hurt.

On one of the weekend shows, it was recently revealed that Trump has a gigantic exaggerated fear of nuclear war.  He also clearly has a thing for strongmen.

January 23, 2024

Hamas Israeli War

Numerous nations are lining up against Israel and demanding a Palestinian state be part of a peace package, even though such a state, if within the boundaries of the former Palestinian mandate, would not be economically viable.  

Saudi Arabia, with a large landmass and a labor deficit, has stated it will not normalize relations with Israel unless a Palestinian state is created.

British and American forces hit Houthi ones again.

Russo Ukrainian War

Ukraine conducted successful drone strikes against targets in Leningrad and Tula oblasts.

Boarder Crisis

The U.S. Supreme Court allowed Federal agents to remove razor wire on the Texas/Mexico border, but it is merely a ruling on a temporary injunction, so the actual ruling, in terms of the issues, means next to nothing whatsoever.

January 24, 2024

Russo Ukrainian War

Due to political infighting, the US is out of funding for Ukraine and the pipeline is therefore shut.

January 25, 2024

Hamas Israeli War

From ISW:

Israel proposed a two-month pause in fighting in exchange for Hamas releasing over several phases the remaining hostages held in the Gaza Strip. The first phase would have Hamas return women, men over 60 years old, and hostages in critical medical condition. Israeli media reported that the "next phases" would include the release of female IDF soldiers, civilian males under the age of 60, Israeli male soldiers, and the bodies of hostages. An anonymous Israeli official told an Israeli journalist that the proposal includes redeploying the IDF out of main population centers in the Gaza Strip to allow Palestinian civilians to return to these areas. The official added that this proposal does not include the release of all 6,000 Palestinian prisoners from Israeli prisons.

This would be a major concession from Israel, but it doesn't seem to have generated much news.

Russo Ukrainian War

A Russian Il-76 military transporting Ukrainian POWs for an exchange crashed in Yablonovo, Belgorod Oblast. The Russians have accused Ukraine of shooting it down.

Patriarch Krill urged the Russian government to extend the draft deferment for fathers, now set at fathers with four children, down to father's with three, out of concern for the declining Russian population.

Slovakia, whose current government is close to Putin, pleadged support for the integrity of Ukraine's internationally recognized borders.

Middle East

Houthi's attempted to attack U.S. Navy escorts with ballistic missiles unsuccessfully.

US/Mexico Border

An attempt in Congress to get a bill passed to address the border is stalled with Donald Trump now entering the picture, opposing it, something that is hard not to be quite skeptical about.

This will messs up aid to Ukraine as well.

January 27, 2024

Russo Ukrainian War

US/Mexico Border

January 27, 2024

Speaker of the House Mike Johnson declared that a budget measure that the Senate did pass providing aid to Ukraine and addressing the US/Mexico border may be dead on arrival at the House.

Trump appears to wish to preserve the border issues, and a second of today's GOP opposes aid to Ukraine.  An unresolved weirdness of populist and Putin, acquired from Trump, remains unresolved.

Also:

Governor Gordon Supports Texas’ Right to Secure its Border

CHEYENNE, Wyo. – Governor Gordon has issued a statement in support of border security Texas Governor Greg Abbott and Texas’ constitutional right to defend and protect itself in the face of the crisis at the southern border.

“I remain committed to a secure border, and to supporting states struggling with the ongoing security crisis along our southern border. That’s why Wyoming has offered resources and committed them to this effort, most recently responding to Governor Greg Abbott's  Emergency Management Assistance Compact (EMAC) request for law enforcement officers. I recognize the importance of secure borders and the vulnerabilities that a lack of resolve to securing those borders has brought to our country.

Secure borders prevent criminals and deadly drugs like fentanyl from entering our country and making their way to Wyoming. Wyoming stands in solidarity with Governor Abbott and the State of Texas in utilizing every tool and strategy to secure the border and protect American citizens. We are all border states now.”

Governor Gordon was also one of 25 Governors who signed a joint statement in support of Texas Governor Abbott and Texas’ constitutional right to self-defense.

Related to this, Denver Colorado reports it has an illegal/refugee populaton of 40,000.

Middle East

The Houthi's hit and set on faire an oil tanker.

China v The West

China’s intelligence agency has warned the Chinese to beware of “exotic beauties” who they fear are opserating as honey traps.

Intersingly, honey traps were a favorite Communist tactic for gathering intelligence.

Hamas Israeli War

Numerous Western countries have suspended contributions to the United Nations Relief and Works Agency, UNRWA, after it was learned that twelve of its members particpated in the Hamas attacks on Israel.

January 28, 2024

Picking up where we left off yesterday:

Hamas Israeli War

Numerous Western countries have suspended contributions to the United Nations Relief and Works Agency, UNRWA, after it was learned that twelve of its members particpated in the Hamas attacks on Israel.

The agency's head warns that UNRWA is collapsing given that nine countries have withdrawn from it and famine looms.

This is a tragedy, but it also tells us something about the UN and th total lack of viability of the Palestinian Authority's territorial regions, although of course a war is on.

Clearly, something needs to be done. That something, requires new oversight, and some hard decisions that nobody wants to make.

January 29, 2024

The Middle East

Three American troops were killed and more injured by an Iranian backed militia drone strike on a US base in Jordan.  The base is near the border with Jordan.

I was unaware we had any bases in Jordan.

January 31, 2024

Russo Ukrainian War

The Russians have launched an offensive in the Kharkiv-Luhansk Oblast

Last Prior Edition:

Wars and Rumors of War, 2023, Part XII. γλυκύ δ᾽ἀπείρῳ πόλεμος. πεπειραμένων δέ τις ταρβεῖ προσιόντα νιν καρδία περισσῶς.

Tuesday, November 7, 2023

Wednesday, November 7, 1973. Congress overrides Nixon's veto of the War Powers Act.

 Congress overrode President Nixon's veto of the War Powers Act.


The resolution was a direct byproduct of the Vietnam War, with Congress feeling that it had basically been led into war without a proper chance to vote on troop deployments to the conflict, although it had voted on the murky Gulf of Tonkin Resolution.  The still relatively fresh Korean War was also in mind.

The Constitutionality of the act, which as been questioned, has never been tested by the Supreme Court.  So far, however, Congress and the President have generally complied with it, not wanting to test it, even though early on President's would note that they felt it to be unconstitutional.  This is discussed further with a link here:

November 7, 1973 – Congress Passes the War Powers Act

Nixon addressed the nation on "The Energy Emergency".



It's fair  to ask in a way if the "Energy Crisis" presented a lost opportunity.

Even in 1973, contrary to the way some would like to assert it, there were concerns in the scientific community about climate change.  When the Energy Crisis arose due to the Arab Oil Embargo there was a serious effort to look at alternative energy sources, although nothing like there is today, and it was coupled with a massive effort to increase the production of domestic fossil fuels.  Solar energy was looked at seriously for the first time.  A lot of thought was put into home solar.  Energy saving regulations, in regard to appliances, and fuel efficiency standards were put into place as well.

Had the government gone further, and moved towards home solar in a large-scale way, and undertook efforts then to look towards conversion to non emitting energy sources, we may well have avoided what we're looking at today.

The Cape Krusenstern Archaeological District in Alaska was designated.


About the location, the National Park Service notes:

Cape Krusenstern Archaeological District - Designated November 7, 1973

Wednesday, September 13, 2023

Thursday, September 13, 1943. Wunderwaffe

The HMHS Newfoundland, a hospital ship, was hit by a German glide bomb in the Mediterranean, while the HMS Uganda was hit by a guided German bomb.

The new German areal munition technology was taking quite a toll.

The HMS Uganda.

The Newfoundland had to be scuttled.  The Uganda was heavily damaged, but returned to service in 1944 as a Canadian ship. She'd see service again during the Korean War as the HMCS Quebec.

The US began to distribute residents of the Tule Lake Relocation Center, which was being converted to a maximum security detention center for Nisei regarded as a significant threat.

Hitler told his aid Karl Wolff that he wanted Pope Pius XII deported to Germany.  On the same day, German emissary to the Vatican Ernst von Weiszacker delivered Hitler's assurances to the Vatican that its sovereignty would be respected.

German counterattacks at Salerno came within one mile of the beaches before being stopped by naval gunfire.  Units from the 82nd Airborne were parachuted in as reinforcements.

In Greece, the Italian Acqui Division resisted German efforts to disarm it.

American actor David Bacon was murdered in Santa Monica.  Surviving a knifing long enough to attempt to drive off, he was found barely alive in his car, wearing only a swimsuit.  He left a pregnant wife. Twenty-nine years old at the time, the mystery has never been solved.

Thursday, May 11, 2023

Tuesday, May 11, 1943. Retaking Attu.

The Navy, supported by the Royal Canadian Air Force, landed elements of 7th Infantry Division on Attu in order to retake the Japanese occupied island.  The resulting battle was the only land battle on American territory during World War Two and the only battle between the US and Japan in the Arctic.


Fighting would cover two weeks with the Japanese putting up a stout defense.  The Japanese Navy formed a task force to relieve the island but the Allies took it before it cold depart Tokyo Bay.  Knowing that they would not be relieved, the Japanese forces went down on May 29 in a banzai charge.  Of the entire Japanese garrison of over 2,800 men, only 28 survived.

Casualties of the final charge.

The 7th Infantry Division was committed to the war in the Pacific for the balance of World War Two, and would have occupation duty in Japan and Korea after the war.  It was stationed in Japan when the Korean War broke out.   During the Korean War, the then under strength division took on an international character, incorporating very large numbers of South Korean troops, as well as Columbian and Ethiopian solders.

Secretary of the Navy publically stated that "Possession of Sicily by the Allies would obviously be a tremendous asset" leading to fears that he'd blow the success of Operation Mincemeat.  Instead, it convinced the Germans that he was trying a "smoke screen".

Friday, January 27, 2023

January 27, 1973. The Paris Peace Accords Signed and last combat casualty sustained.

Secretary of State William Rogers signing the Vietnam Peace Accords.

The following agreements were signed on this day in Paris, between the warring parties in Vietnam.

"Protocol Concerning the Cease-Fire in South Vietnam and the Joint Military Commission"

"Protocol Concerning the Return of Captured Military Personnel and Foreign Civilians and the Captured and Detained Vietnamese Civilian Personnel"

"Protocol Concerning the International Commission of Control and Supervision "

"Protocol Concerning the Removal, Permanent Deactivation, or Destruction of Mines in the Territorial Waters, Ports, Harbors, and Waterways of the Democratic Republic of Vietnam"

The agreements paved the way for the United States to exit Vietnam under the fiction that "peace with honor" had been brought to South Vietnam.  In reality, the fighting never fully stopped and the Nixon Administration expected South Vietnam to fall.  The South was pressured into signing the agreement.

By this point in the war, the US had largely withdrawn its combat troops from Vietnam.  The final ones would be withdrawn in March, by which time it was obvious that the war was continuing on.  As a practical matter, disciplinary problems in the US military were, by that point, so severe, that the Army was close to becoming incapable of engaging in combat operations.  To this extent, the North Vietnamese had truly defeated the US in the ground war, although US air cover remained potent up until the ceasefire took place.

On this day, U.S. Army Col. William Nolde was killed by Communist artillery fire. He is generally regarded as the last American combat casualty of the Vietnam War, although Marines Charles McMahon and Darwin Lee Judge were killed by a North Vietnamese rocket attack on April 29, 1975, just before Saigon fell.  The distinction, if there is one, is that Nolde was assigned to a combat command. 

Nolde had been a Korean War conscript, and stayed in the Army thereafter, becoming an officer.  His first tour of duty was in 1965.

Nolde had been a professor of military science at Central Michigan University before being conscripted, so he had the somewhat peculiar experience of being a university professor on military matters before being an enlisted man in the Korean War, and an officer in the Vietnam War.  A scholarship at Central Michigan was established in his memory.

Thursday, January 26, 2023

Friday, January 26, 1973. The Battle of Battle of Cửa Việt.

The Battle of Battle of Cửa Việt took place one day prior to the Vietnam War supposed cease fire coming into effect as the ARVN and South Vietnamese Marines, supported by US air cover, attempted to retake the port of Cửa Việt in Quang Tri Province.  The battle spilled on over to January 31 before it concluded.

Late war efforts such as this were also common to the Korean War.

The effort was unsuccessful.

The battle was also telling. The effort relied upon US air cover, in this instance supplied by the Navy and Air Force.  

The peace was supposed to take effect immediately, but never really did.

The Convention for the Suppression of Unlawful Acts against the Safety of Civil Aviation went into effect.


Screen legend Edward G. Robinson, who is principally remembered for playing tough guys in the movies of the 30s and 40s, died at age 79.

Robinson was born Menashe  Goldenberg in Bucharest to a Jewish Romanian family in 1893. The family moved to the United States in 1904.  He joined the U.S. Navy in World War One, and served stateside.  He was already acting before the war, although he'd originally planned on being a lawyer.  He acted up into 1972.

Friday, October 21, 2022

Wednesday, October 21, 1942. Mark Clark's Mission, Eddie Rickenbacker's plight.

Clark in November, 1942.
Today in World War II History—October 21, 1942: Maj. Gen. Mark Clark lands by submarine at Cherchel, Algeria, for a clandestine meeting with the Vichy French in preparation for the upcoming Allied invasion.
From Sarah Sundin's blog.

The photogenic Clark was a favorite of the Press during the early part of World War Two. This event, resulting in the beginning of the formal separation of the French military from Vichy, may have been the high point, in real terms, of his career.  His later command in Italy, where he was in command until the war's end, has been subject to less impressive analysis by historians, and he was held in bitter contempt by veterans of the 36th Infantry Division who had taken huge casualties trying to cross the Rapido.  The sought, and received, a post-war Congressional investigation of that incident, for which Clark was cleared.

During the Korean War he was commander of the United Nations forces following the command of Matthew Ridgeway.  He occupied that role from May 12, 1952 until the armistice was signed on July 27, 1953.  He retired that following October, after which he became president of The Citadel.  He died in 1988, at age 84.

That last item is worth considering.  It means, for example, that when Clark was dispatched to negotiate with the French, he was 41, and when World War Two ended he was 44, younger than we often imagine World War Two generals to be.  In reality, in the U.S. Army, they tended to be relatively young.

Sundin also reports that a B-17D provided by the Army to Eddie Rickenbacker went down in the Pacific.  Rickenbacker was on a tour of Pacific air bases to review operations and living conditions.  Faulty navigational equipment caused the plane to go widely off course and run out of fuel over the open ocean.  The crew was adrift thereafter for twenty-four days before being picked, with one of the men dying from dehydration.  Ultimately, the men split up in lift rafts at sea, but they were found.

The experience caused the Navy to alter life raft equipment to incorporate fishing equipment in them.

She also notes that the Revenue Act of 1942 went into effect in the US, which increased individual income tax rates and corporate tax rates, with top tax rates going from 31% to 40%.  The act also reduced personal exemptions.  An excess profits tax of 90% was also put in effect.  Medical expenses became a deduction for the first time.

The war ushered in an era of generally high upper tax rates that remained in effect for the next couple of decades, meaning that they remained high during the boom years of the 1950s.  The concept that American tax rates were unfairly high really didn't come about until Ronald Reagan's presidency.

Wednesday, September 21, 2022

Monday, September 21, 1942. First flight of the B-29

 YB-29s.

Today in World War II History—September 21, 1942: British and Indian troops launch assault into the Arakan Peninsula in Burma. First test flight of Boeing XB-29 Superfortress heavy bomber, Seattle, WA.

From Sarah Sundin's blog.

The B-29 was one of the great aircraft of the Second World War and was also, during the war, one that was downright dangerous to fly due to its frequent engine failures and fires.  It's loss rate early on in China, from which many were flown, was appalling.  Nonetheless, they were an advance that could be regarded as generational.

Forever associated with Hiroshima and Nagasaki, the plane became the world's first nuclear bomber, a status it retained for a while post-war.  By the Korean War, however, they were beginning to show their vulnerabilities in the new jet and rocket age. The B-36 resulted in them being reclassified as a medium bomber, an odd thought, and the B-29 was retired in 1960, and overall long run for a bomber of that period.  A late variant, the B-29D, which was reclassified as the B-50, continued on in limited use until 1963.  Ironically, a version copied by the Soviet Union from an example that landed on their territory during the war, the TU-4, remained in active service slightly longer and also saw service with the Red Chinese, meaning that for a time the airplane equipped both sides in the Cold War.

B-50.

The aircraft was not introduced into service until 1944 and its use was limited to the CBI and Pacific Theaters. Post-war, the British were briefly equipped with a limited number, a small number of which went on to serve with Australia.  An airliner version went on to become an early post-war transoceanic airliner, one of the ones that effectively put an end to flying boats.

Tuesday, June 14, 2022

Wednesday, June 14, 1922. Birth of Robin Olds

 


Legendary fighter pilot Robert "Robin" Olds, Jr., son of an Army Air Corps officer of the same name, was born this day in Hawaii.

He became a triple ace, scoring kills in World War Two, Korea and Vietnam, and retired as a Brigadier General in 1973.  His father had been a Major General.

Olds was a larger than life character in every way.  He was married for many years to starlet Ella Raines, although their marriage eventually ended in divorce and he remarried (he still came in at half the total number of marriages than his father).  His penchant for drinking likely kept him from rising higher in the Air Force than he did.  He served on the Steamboat Springs Planning Commission in retirement.

He died in 2007 at age 84.

Sunday, April 24, 2022

Replacing old weapons where they don't need to be, and making a choice for a new one that's long overdue. Part 2

Okay, we just went on and on about the history of the U.S. service rifle and the adoption of the XM8.

Aren't we going to say anything about the new XM250 Automatic Rifle?

Well, the first thing we'll say is that it isn't an "automatic rifle".  The Army doesn't have an "automatic rifle"

It's a light machinegun.

Okay, other than being super snarky, what's up with that comment, and the XM250.

SIG Sauer photograph of the XM250.

In this instance, let's start with desscribing what the XM250 is.

It's a 6.8x51 light belt fed machinegun of conventional design, but advanced materials, which will replace the M249 "Squad Automatic Weapon" in the Army.  The M249, in the "automatic rifle" role it is slotted in, is issued as follows:


In other words, a current U.S. Army rifle squad is led by a Staff Sergeant, and it is split into two subsquads, each led by a Sergeant.* The entire squad has only two privates,a nd four specialists.  Each subsquad has one M203 grenade launcher, which is a M4/Grenade launcher combo, and one M249.  The subsquads are really built around the M249.

If this sounds vaguely familiar, and maybe it should, it vaguely resembles the concept of the German Army of World War Two, which was based on rifleman support of the squad machinegunner.  It's also vaguely similar to the US Marine Corps squad of World War Two, which also included two automatic riflemen by the war's end.

And now, yes, a little history.  And yes, like many things here, we've dealt with this history here before.

Infantry squads, prior to 1917, were formed by lining men in a company up and counting them out into groups of eight men per squad.  Each squad would have a corporal in charge of it and consist of eight men, including the commanding corporal.  The corporal, in terms of authority, and in reality, was equivalent to a sergeant in the Army post 1921.  I.e., the corporal was equivalent to a modern sergeant in the Army.  He was, we'd note, a true Non-Commissioned Officer.   This basic organization continued on through 1921, when thing were much reorganized.  But the basic structure of the Rifle Company itself was about to change dramatically, in part due to advancements in small arms which were impacting the nearly universal identify of the infantryman as a rifleman.

Colorado National Guardsman with M1895 machinegun in 1914, at Ludlow Colorado.

Automatic weapons were coming into service, but how to use and issue them wasn't clear at first.  The U.S. Army first encountered them in the Spanish American War, which coincidentally overlapped with the Boer War, which is where the British Army first encountered and used them.  The US adopted its first machinegun in 1895.  The 1st U.S. Volunteer Cavalry, which fought as dismounted cavalry in Cuba during the Spanish American War, used them in support of their assault of Kettle Hill, although theirs were privately purchased by unit supporters who had donated them to the unit.   The Spanish American and Boer Wars proved their utility however, and various models came after that.  They were, however, not assigned out at the squad level, but were retained in a separate company and assigned out by higher headquarters as needed.  There was, in other words, no organic automatic weapon at the company level, and certainly not at the squad level.

There also weren't a lot of them.  Running up to World War One, the Army issued new tables of organization for National Guard units, anticipating large formations such as divisions.  Even at that point, however, there were no automatic weapons at the company level at all.  The infantry regiment table provided for a Machine Gun Company, which had a grand total of four automatic rifles. 

M1909 "Machine Rifle".  It was a variant of the Hotchkiss machinegun of the period and was acquired by the Army in very low quantities.  Loved by other armies, the Ameican Army hated it.

Just four.

Most men in a Rifle Company were riflemen.  Automatic weapons were issued to special sections.  Most of the infantry, therefore that served along the border with Mexico during the Punitive Expection, just prior to the Great War, was leg infantry, carrying M1903 Springfield rifles, and of generally low rank.  They didn't have much to do with machineguns.

New York National Guardsmen in Texas during the Punitive Expedition.

At that time, an infantry company had about 100 men, commanded by a captain who had a very small staff.  The entire company, for that matter, had an economy of staff.  Most of the men were privates, almost all of which were riflemen, and most of whose direct authority figure, if you will, was a corporal. There were few sergeants in the company, and those who were there were pretty powerful men, in context.  There were some men around with special skills as well, such as buglers, farriers, and cooks.  Cooks were a specialty and the cook was an NCO himself, showing how important he was.  Even infantry had a small number of horses for officers and potentially for messengers, which is why there were farriers.  And automatic weapons had started to show up, but not as weapons assigned to the company itself, and not in large numbers.

Running up to the war, however, the Army started to make massive changes in organization in order to contemplate largescale warfare in France. Those changes went down to the squad level.  By the time the US committed to the Great War, an infantry platoon was composed of four sections comprised of grenadiers (hand grenades), rifle grenadiers, riflemen, and automatic riflemen. This organization is confusing to those familiar with later developments, as it resembled the later squad, on a much larger organizational scale.  The basic organization was as follows:

4 Rifle Platoons per Company (1 Officer and 58 Enlisted each) 

1 ​Platoon Headquarters

  • 1× Platoon Commander, Lieutenant, armed with 1 pistol/revolver and no rifle, except in reality, he often carried a rifle.

  • 1× Platoon Sergeant, Sergeant, armed with 1 M1903/M1917 rifle and 1 pistol or revolver and no rifle, except. . . . 

  • 4× Runners, Private, armed with 1 M1903/M1917 rifle, theoretically, but often armed with a M1911.
     

​1 Hand Bomber (Grenadier) Section.  Yes, a section of grenadiers.

  • 3× Hand Bomber Teams of:

    • 1× Team Leader, Corporal (2 teams) or Private First Class (1 team), armed with 1 M1903/M1917 rifle and, for Corporal team leaders, 1 pistol/revolver

    • 1× Thrower, Private First Class, armed with 1 M1903/M1917 rifle and 1 pistol/revolver

    • 1× Scout, Private, armed with 1 M1903/M1917 rifle

    • 1× Ammo Man, Private, armed with 1 M1903/M1917 rifle

​1× Rifle Grenadier Section

  • 3× Rifle Grenadier Teams of:

    • 1× Team Leader, Corporal (2 teams) or Private First Class (1 team), armed with 1 M1903/M1917 rifle, 1 VB grenade launcher and, for Corporal team leaders, 1 pistol/revolver

    • 1× Gunner, Private First Class, armed with 1 M1903/M1917 rifle and VB grenade launcher

    • 1× Ammo Man, Private, armed with 1 M1903/M1917 rifle

​1× Automatic Rifle Section

  • 1× Section Leader, Sergeant, armed with 1 M1903/M1917 rifle and 1 pistol/revolver

  • 2× Automatic Rifle Squads of:

    • 1× Squad Leader, Corporal, armed with 1 M1903/M1917 rifle and 1 pistol/revolver

    • 2× Automatic Riflemen [B], Private First Class, armed with 1 M1915 Chauchat automatic rifle [C] and 1 pistol/revolver each

    • 4× Ammo Man, Private, armed with 1 M1903/M1917 rifle each

1× Rifle Section

  • 1× Section Leader, Sergeant, armed with 1 M1903/M1917 rifle

  • 2× Rifle Squads of:

    • 1× Squad Leader, Corporal, armed with 1 M1903/M1917 rifle

    • 7× Riflemen, Private First Class (3 men) or Private (4 men), armed with 1 M1903/M1917 rifle each

If that's a bit confusing, and outside of our normal experiences in this area, the weapons used may be more so.  But to note, this large maneuver element was busted up and deployed as needed, but nowhere near on the downscale that we now find.

Going into the war, the US had two good fully automatic weapons, and one so/so one.

 Model 1904 Maxim .30-06 machine guns in use by U.S. cavalrymen.  Note that these cavalrymen also carry M1911 pistols.  The cavalryman pointing is wearing a holster for the M1911 that was unique to cavalry, as it swiveled.  The machine gun crewmen are wearing the general issue M1911 holster.

The first true machine gun used by the U.S. Army was John Browning's M1895.  Manufactured in a variety of calibers and sold worldwide, in U.S. use it started off in .30-40 and in 6mm Navy Lee.  In spite of the fact that the Army never officially adopted them, they showed up in use more often than a person might suppose as National Guard units often simply bought them, in a variety of calibers.  During the Spanish American War two were given as gifts to the 1st U.S. Volunteer Cavalry by family members of the unit, although oddly those were in 7x57, the cartridge used by Spain.  The unofficial nature of this use in Army hands (Navy and Marine Corps use was official) meant that the gun was still in use in various units as late as 1917 when the United States entered World War one.

 

Machine gun troop in Mexico.

The M1895 was not a bad gun, but it was a very early gun, and it was clearly a pioneering, and therefore not fully satisfactory, weapon.   It was delicate and prone to stoppages.  The experience of the Spanish Civil War showed that another weapon would have to be found, as its operational rate fared poorly in comparison with the obsolete Gatlings.

 

Schematic of the Colt-Browing, "Potato Digger"

Fortunately, there was a ready alternative to the M1895 available, that being the Maxim gun.

 

M1904 Maxim in use in Texas in 1911.

The Maxim gun was a heavy machine gun designed by American-born Hiram Maxim.  A visionary weapon, Maxim first introduced the gun in 1886, shortly after he had relocated to the United Kingdom.  The heavy recoil operated gun would set the standard for heavy machine guns, a position which to some degree it still occupied.  Maxim's gun came right at the end of the black powder era and because of the nature of its design it was suitable for any of the then existing cartridges as well as the smokeless cartridges that were just being invented.  Indeed, the gun was so adaptable that some of the larger variants of it were really automatic cannons due to the virtue of their size.

The Army started testing the Maxim relatively early on, but it was slow to adopt it, perhaps in part as the Army had a hard time figuring out exactly how to deploy machine guns at first.  Indeed, nearly every Army had difficulty in this department.  In 1904, however, the Army adopted the Maxim as the Army's first machine gun.  Production, however, was slow, with initial production taking place in the UK for weapons chambered in .30-03 and remaining production undertaken by Colt.  Only 287 of the guns were made, but as the picture above shows, they were deployed along the border and they were very good guns.  They were also extremely heavy, both because of the heavy weight of the action and because the gun was water cooled. For an introductory weapon, it was excellent, but the Army had already adopted a replacement by the time of the Punitive Expedition.

In the meantime, the Army was also experimenting with light machine guns and adopted a true light machinegun by 1909, as the M1909..

 U.S. Troops firing the M1909 Benét–Mercié machine gun, a variant of the Hotchkiss light machine gun.

The entire story of the M1909 is an odd one, as the gun itself is a legendary weapon, one of the Hotchkiss machine guns. The Hotchkiss machine guns saw service around the globe and were generally well liked by most armies. The U.S. Army ended up not liking the gun.  All in all, the M1909 acquired a bad reputation in the U.S. Army during the Punitive Expedition, even though reports of its use really don't support that feeling, and it was a better gun than the one that would go on to be used in the same role during World War One.

The US was also using the Lewis Gun, a truly excellent light machinegun, for the time, leading up to World War One.

The Lewis Gun was introduced by its designer around 1911 and received some use early on.  Unfortunately for the Army, it seems that a dislike on the part of the chief of the Army of the inventor kept it from being adopted by the U.S. Army for a light machine gun, a decision that would have consequences during World War One.  Given the nature of the times, however, the gun was picked up privately by at least one small National Guard unit that was funded heavily by a member, in an era when that sort of thing was still not uncommon.  But Guard units did not cross the border, they only guarded it, during the Punitive Expedition.  The gun would see heavy use by the British during World War One and on into World War Two, and by the U.S. Navy and Marine Corps, but not by the Army during the Great War, even though it was showing up in the Army prior to that.

Marine training with Lewis Gun

Indeed, during the Great War, the Army was armed with the Chauchat, which was a disaster.

The Chauchat was a French designed automatic rifle, not a light machinegun. Designed to be used automatically as its infantryman moved forward, it was supposed to sweep away enemy opposition in front of it.  This was a common concept for automatic rifles at the time, and wholly unrealistic.

U.S. infantrymen training with Chauchat's in 1919 at Ft. Custer, South Dakota.

It's apologist claim that the American .30-06 version of the Chauchat was badly made, and its opponents claim that they all were, but anyway a person looks at it, the jam prone Chauchat was so bad that American infantrymen commonly dropped it and simply picked up a rifle in combat.  Therefore, whatever the TO&E showed, it was providing little support to anyone, no matter how deployed.  

The American solder on the left is equipped with the terrible Chauchat Mle 1918

Backing the infantry up, however, were  British and French heavy machine guns.  By the end of the war native designs had been adopted by the US in the form of the M1917 heavy machine gun, a Browning design, and the M1918 Browning Automatic Rifle.

Val Browning firing an example of his father's M1917 machinegun.

In the late stages of the Great War the M1918 Browning Automatic Rifle, which became the standard light machinegun of the U.S. Army for the next forty plus years.  As its name indicates, it was, however, designed as an automatic rifle, not a light machinegun.  Highly mechanically reliable, however, and not as heavy as the Lewis Gun, it was fairly modern at the time it was adopted, and naturally kept on as the post-war light machinegun for the infantry and cavalry, with the cavalry having its own version termed a "machine rifle".





After the First World War, the Army, based on its experiences in the war and its greater appreciation of what automatic weapons mean, revised the infantry platoon significant and created the infantry squad. At this point, the squad starts to become quite recognizable, smaller and backed up by a light machinegun in the form of hte BAR.  In the cavalry it was similiar, except the cavalry had its own BAR version, which was termined a "machine rifle".

After the First World War, the Army, based on its experiences in the war and its greater appreciation of what automatic weapons meant, revised the infantry platoon significant and created the infantry squad. At this point, the squad starts to become quite recognizable.    By World War Two, the Army's infantry squad looked like this:



When properly constituted, it was led by a Sergeant (E4 at the time, equivalent to the modern Specialist or Corporal in grade), with an assistant squad leader who was a Corporal. Everyone else was a private of some sort. The two NCOs and the riflemen were all armed with M1 Garands.  The Scouts were supposed to be armed with M1903 bolt actions, but were often armed with M1 Garands.  The Automatic Rifleman carried a BAR.

In the Marine Corps, however, the wartime organization developed into a different configuration.  Marine Corps squads were split in half, and two BARs were issued.

In both the Marines and the Army BARs were often stripped of their bipods and used as automatic rifles by default.  This was frankly less than an ideal situation, and it meant that while the US was fortunate to have a weapon that other nations did not, a functioning automatic rifle, it meant they lacked a more important one, a good light machinegun.  A couple of efforts were made to address it, some minor, and one major, influenced by the interwar German development of the General Purpose Machine Gun.

The Germans had never been impressed with the automatic rifle and never bothered with them.  During World War One, they fielded a really heavy light machinegun based on the Maxim 08 and ultimately pioneered the very late war development of the submachinegun.  German infantrymen were backed up by a heavy Maxim.

By Oberfeldarzt Dr. Paul Calwer - Persönlicher Nachlass (abfotografiert vom Originalabzug), CC BY-SA 4.0, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=80920917

Between the wars, the Germans went to a nine man squad consisting of nine men and one squad leader.  One of the nine men was a machine gunner issued a MG34, or later on a MG42, belt fed weapons that could act as heavy light machineguns or mobile medium guns.  The concept was revolutionary.  All the other men in the squad supported the machine gunner.

By Bundesarchiv, Bild 101I-204-1727-18 / Grah / CC-BY-SA 3.0, CC BY-SA 3.0 de, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=5476452

Everyone facing the Germans was generally impressed with the MG34 and the MG42, even if they didn't adopt the same squad organization.  The US took a run at duplicating the concept, however, with the M1919A6 machinegun, which was simply the M1919 with a bipod and a stock.  It wasn't great, but it was better than nothing.   And for a mediocre weapon, it had a pretty long run.

M1919A6 in the 1950s.

What all of this means is that the Army infantry squad of World War Two had one BAR or one M1919A6, and everybody else carried a rifle. The Marine Corps squad started off that way, but by the end of the war, it had two BAR men.

By the Korean War, the Army squad had been reduced to nine men, something that had been contemplated during World War Two.   The war caught the Army off guard, and frankly in a state of neglect by Congress, which had not anticipated future conventional wars occurring. Work was occurring on new weapons, but with vast amounts of weapons left over from the Second World War, this had not been occurring with a sense of urgency.

The Korean War squad, therefore, was sort of a make do affair, but it very clearly pointed the direction that things were headed in. The nine man squad was busted into two subsquads, each of which had one BAR.

After the Korean War, the Army bizarrely increased the size of the squad again, something that developments in World War Two and Korea had pointed against.   The squad was increased to eleven men, rivaling its World War Two size.  It was a bad trend.  Be that as it may, in the mid 1950s, that eleven men squad was eleven riflemen, armed with M1 Garands, and one BAR man or one man armed with a M1919A6.

Selective fire M1 Garand

In the late stages of the Second World War, the Army was experimenting with new squad automatic weapons.  One concept was for a selective fire M1 Garand to replace the BAR in the upcoming invasion of Japan. That was a bad idea that the early end of the war prevented from being introduced.  A better idea was a weapon designed as a GPMG.

M60.  I have some personal expeience with carrying these around.

The Army oddly determined to base its design on the FG42, not the MG42, and introduced an experimental model as early as 1944.  With work on the 7.62 NATO progressing, the design was complete by the late 1950s and in 1957 the new GMPG was introduced as the M60.  Oddly, however, the Army took an extremely conservative approach and determined to also introduce a new light machinegun, the M15, based on the M14 action.



The M15 proved to be an immediate disaster.  It had all the defects of the BAR, including a bottom feeding 20 round magazine, with none of its virtues. The M14 was a great rifle, but it was a lousy machinegun, and the M15 proved to be a failure almost as soon as it was introduced.  Not willing to give up on the concept, the Army reengineered the M14 again for a second attempt, with the M14E2 being the result, the E indicating that the weapon was not yet standardized.



The M14E2 was deployed to Vietnam, but it simply didn't work in its intended role. In the Marine Corps, the decision was to keep the BAR in its existing role, the Marines being big fans of the BAR in the first place.  In the Army, the M14E2 was withdrawn and the M60 simply filled the gap at first, just as the original GPMGs had. 

Early on, the Army in Vietnam went to a fire team approach based on its big squad.  Each squad had two fire teams, and each fire team had a fire team leader, a grenadier armed with a M79 grenade launcher, and an "automatic rifleman" armed with an M60, an assistant gunner. The balance of the squad was made up of three infantrymen who were not permanently assigned.  With the introduction of the M16, an attempt was made to assign one rifleman in each fire team as an automatic rifleman, equipped with a bipod for his M16, but it was an absurd idea.  For the most part, whether the fire team was armed with M14s or M16s, the M60 was the squad automatic weapon.



In the late 1970s, the Army and Marine Corps adopted the M240, which was a legendary Belgian GPMG often called the MAG.  It's a great weapon, but its adoption was wholly unnecessary, as there was nothing wrong with the M60.  The M240, for all its virgues, is a massively bulky weapon and with teh earlier introduction of the M16 it came to be the case that the squad now was carrying longarms that used two different types of ammunition.

Efforts to come up with an effective 5.56 light machingun had been going on since the Vietnam War, and indeed the Navy had deployed one in the form of the Stoner 63 designed by, yes of course, Eugene Stoner.  Work continued after the war, and by the late 1970s the Belgian Minimi had pulled ahead and was ultimately adopted by the US as the M249.

U.S. Navy Seal with a Stoner 63.

And that has been the situation ever since.

Today, the squad is made up as depicted above. The squad automatic weapons are M249s.  No matter what people want to call them, they're machineguns, not "automatic rifles". That's just a bit of talk recalling an earlier era.  U.S. infantrymen have not carried an automatic rifle since the BAR was finally phased out of the National Guard in the late 1970s.


So, what's wrong with that?

Well, the 5.56.

The 5.56 just won't reach out and everybody knows it. That's why the M240 and indeed the M60 are still around. When a real machinegun is required, it's going to be the M240 or the M60. The M240 is issued at the platoon level, so there's not one far away.

With the introduction of the new 6.8 round, a new machinegun for the "automatic rifleman" role is an absolute must.  Riflemen can't be carrying a longer range weapon than their supporting automatic weapon.  And the new SIG design is a good one.

Oddly, however, the M240 will be retained, and for that there's no need.  It ought to go.

And then there's the Marine Corps.

As we've noted, the Marines aren't adopting the 6.8, at leat yet.

And they are dumping the M249.

Their current rifle, the M27, was originally designed to be a true automatic rifle, so by adopting it, the Marines originally intended to take a giant leap backwards towards the BAR.

Which was a mistake.

But it's what they did, replacing the M4 carbine and the M249 with the M27, placing them in a situation which really hasn't existed, in a way, since before World War One.

They do retain the M240.  But they're also openly holding out to adopt SIG's .338 MG 338, a GPMG that shoots the .338 Win Mag.

True, it will really reach out there, but . . . .

Prior and related threads: